Saving vs. Investing: How They Differ and Which is Better for You

When it comes to personal finance, saving and investing are fundamental concepts that often get mixed up. While both play crucial roles in achieving various financial goals, they serve different purposes and involve different strategies. It is essential to know the distinct characteristics of saving and investing to effectively manage your finances and determine which approach aligns best with your objectives.

Consulting a financial advisor can be helpful in guiding you in selecting the best strategy for your specific financial goals. This article will also explore how saving and investing differ, their unique pros and cons, and how to determine which method suits your financial needs the best.

What are the seven main differences between saving and investing?

1. Meaning, type, and examples

Savings refers to keeping money aside for future needs or emergencies. The primary goal of saving is to have funds readily available for planned expenses or unforeseen situations while maintaining financial discipline. Savings are typically kept in low-risk accounts focused on preserving the principal amount. Some common savings vehicles include:

• Savings accounts
• Certificates of Deposit (CDs)
• Cash at home

For example, saving $100 each month in a savings account helps you build a safety net for future needs.

On the other hand, investing involves allocating money to market-linked instruments to generate wealth and outpace inflation thanks to compounding. Investing is geared towards achieving financial goals that may seem ambitious initially but can be realized over time. Investment options include:

• Mutual funds
• Stocks
• Bonds
• Real estate

For instance, if you invest $100 in a mutual fund with an annual return of 10% over 10 years, the power of compound interest significantly increases your investment. Here’s how this works:

A = P × (1+r) n

Where,

• P = $100 (initial investment)
• r = 0.10 (10% annual return)
• n = 10 years

A = 100 x (1+ 0.10) 10 = 259.37

So, after 10 years, your $100 investment will grow to approximately $259.37.

2. Return

Understanding the savings vs investment ratio in regard to returns is essential when choosing between the two. Savings typically offer lower returns compared to investing. This is because savings vehicles are designed to preserve capital rather than generate a profit. For instance, a savings account may provide annual interest as a reward for keeping your money with the bank, but these interest rates are generally modest. The primary goal of savings is safety and liquidity rather than growth. Therefore, if you are saving for a significant goal, such as a large purchase or an emergency fund, the return on your savings may be insufficient to meet your objectives within a short timeframe. For substantial financial goals, you may need to set aside money for an extended period to achieve the desired amount through savings alone.

In contrast, investing offers the potential for higher returns. Historically, equities have delivered higher returns than traditional savings methods. For example, the S&P 500 Index, which represents a broad band of the U.S. stock market, has provided an annualized average return of approximately 10.26% from its inception in 1957 through the end of 2023.

Unlike savings, investments involve putting money into assets with the expectation of earning a profit. The returns from investing can vary widely based on the type of investment and its performance. For example, equities, bonds, mutual funds, and real estate each have different return profiles. Nevertheless, over extended periods, the potential for wealth accumulation is generally much greater with all these instruments compared to savings alone.

3. Risk

Return and risk are inherently linked in financial decisions. Generally, higher returns are associated with higher risk, while lower returns correspond to lower risk. Understanding this is crucial when deciding between savings and investments.

Is saving or investing riskier? The simple answer is that investing is riskier. Savings offer minimal risk, which is why they typically provide lower returns. When you save your money in vehicles such as savings accounts, Certificates of Deposit (CDs), etc., the risk of losing your principal is very low. These savings options are designed to protect your capital. Since the risk is minimal, the potential for growth is also limited. Savings accounts and CDs, for example, offer predictable but modest interest rates. This safety comes at the cost of reduced growth potential, making savings suitable for short-term financial goals or emergency funds.

On the other hand, investing presents the opportunity for higher returns but also involves greater risk. Different asset classes carry different risk profiles. For example, stocks are generally considered the riskiest investment option. However, they also offer the potential for high returns over the long term. Bonds are relatively safer than stocks as they provide more stability and income through interest payments, but they typically offer lower returns than equities. Investing in real estate can vary in risk depending on market conditions and other factors, such as location. While it can provide steady rental income and potential capital appreciation, it involves risks such as market fluctuations and repair and maintenance costs.

Each investment type has a unique risk-return profile, and it is important to align your investment choices with your risk tolerance and financial goals. For example, investing in equities might be appropriate if you are willing to take on higher risk for the chance of higher returns. On the other hand, bonds or savings accounts may be more suitable if you prefer stability and lower risk.

4. Cost

Savings accounts may incur annual fees or maintenance charges, but these are generally low and straightforward. Such fees are typically minimal compared to the potential returns, and the costs are relatively easy to manage. Investing, however, involves a more complex cost structure. Investment costs can include brokerage fees, fund management fees, and transaction costs such as entry and exit fees. These fees can vary widely depending on the investment vehicle. For instance, trading stocks involves brokerage commissions. Similarly, 401(k)s may also charge management fees, among other costs.

The costs associated with savings are typically lower and more predictable. In comparison, investing can involve higher fees, but it also offers the potential for greater returns. Therefore, it is essential to evaluate these costs in relation to potential returns to ensure that they do not diminish your overall profits.

Need a financial advisor? Compare vetted advisors matched to your specific requirements.

Choosing the right financial advisor is daunting, especially when there are thousands of financial advisors near you. We make it easy by matching you to vetted advisors that meet your unique needs. Matched advisors are all registered with FINRA/SEC. Click to compare vetted advisors now.

5. Time horizon

The time horizon for both savings and investments can be tailored to suit your financial goals. Savings are versatile and can be employed for both short-term and long-term goals. For short-term needs, such as an emergency fund or a planned purchase, a savings account provides easy access to funds at low risk. Interestingly, savings accounts can still be helpful for long-term goals, like saving for retirement or a child’s education, even though they may offer lower returns. In both cases, the savings rate and account type can be adjusted to align with your time horizon.

Investing also accommodates various time horizons, but different investment instruments are better suited to specific durations. For instance, bonds are generally considered suitable for shorter to medium-term investments. Stocks are typically recommended for long-term investing due to their fluctuating nature in the short term.

6. Liquidity

Savings generally offer high liquidity. Most savings accounts allow you to withdraw cash at any time without facing penalties, making them highly accessible for immediate needs or financial emergencies. However, certain savings instruments like CDs may have specific withdrawal rules. For example, withdrawing funds from a CD before its maturity date might incur early withdrawal penalties. Therefore, it is important to understand the terms and conditions of each savings product before using it.

Investing often involves varying degrees of liquidity depending on the investment type. While you can typically buy and sell stocks or enter and exit mutual funds relatively freely, there are several factors to consider, as explained below:

• Market conditions: The ease of selling investments can be affected by market conditions. For instance, while a stock may be highly liquid, selling it may still be tricky in a volatile market. In most cases, you need to time the market and make strategic decisions.
• Tax implications: Selling investments may trigger tax consequences, such as short and long-term capital gains taxes, which can affect the overall profitability of your assets.
• Account rules: Certain investment accounts, such as 401(k)s and Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs), have restrictions on withdrawals. For instance, you generally cannot withdraw funds from these accounts before age 59.5 years without incurring penalties and additional taxes. Additionally, traditional retirement accounts also have Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs), mandating the time and minimum value of the withdrawals.

7. Protection against inflation

Savings often provide limited protection against inflation. The return on savings accounts and similar low-risk savings instruments is typically minimal. Because inflation erodes the purchasing power of money over time, the modest interest rates offered by savings accounts may not keep up with rising prices. As a result, the real value of your savings can diminish if they are left idle for a long time. For example, if inflation is 5% and the interest earned on your savings is 4%, you may find that the actual value of your savings is lowered rather than increased.

Investing generally offers better protection against inflation. Investments such as stocks, real estate, and certain types of bonds are designed to outpace inflation over time. These assets tend to provide higher returns compared to savings accounts, which helps increase the value of your money. For instance, Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS) are specifically designed to protect against inflation. Similarly, stocks can outpace inflation when invested in the long run.

Saving vs investment – pros and cons

a. Savings

Below are the pros of savings:

• Easy and simple to do: Savings accounts and other savings instruments are straightforward to set up and manage.
• Requires minimal knowledge: No specialized knowledge is needed to start saving.
• Low fees: Generally, savings accounts have low or no fees, and maintenance costs are minimal.
• Low risk: Savings accounts are low risk as they are not exposed to market risk, and institutions like the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) typically insure the principal amount.
• Liquid: Funds in savings accounts are easily accessible, allowing for quick withdrawals when needed.

Below are the cons of savings:

• Low return: Savings accounts typically offer minimal interest rates, resulting in low returns on your money.
• No protection against inflation: The return on savings often fails to keep pace with inflation.

1. Investing

Below are the pros of investing:

• Potential to grow money: Investments have the potential for higher returns compared to savings, which can significantly grow your wealth over time.
• It helps achieve diverse goals: Investing can be tailored to various financial goals, from retirement to purchasing a home.
• Protects against inflation: Many investments, such as stocks and real estate, have the potential to beat inflation.

Below are the cons of investing:

• Costs: Investing often involves costs such as brokerage fees, fund management fees, and transaction costs, which can affect overall returns.
• High risk: Investments come with varying degrees of risk.

Which is better?

The decision between savings and investing depends on your financial goals. Savings are typically ideal if you need to access money in the near future. For instance, if you are planning to purchase a specific item like an electronic appliance, savings accounts offer easy access to your funds and are designed for such purposes. Additionally, savings accounts are well-suited for building an emergency fund to cover unexpected expenses or for paying off high-interest debt.

On the other hand, investing is generally a better option if you do not need the money for at least five years or longer. Investing is more appropriate for long-term financial goals that require substantial funds, such as retirement or a child’s college education. It is ideal for individuals who are comfortable with taking on some level of risk for the potential of higher returns.

Ideally, you should incorporate both strategies into your financial plan.

To conclude

Understanding the differences between savings and investing and knowing how to incorporate both into your financial planning is crucial for achieving a balanced financial strategy. Maintaining the right balance between savings and investing allows you to take advantage of the benefits of both options. It enables you to grow your wealth through investments while keeping a portion of your funds secure in savings accounts for emergencies. Consulting with a financial advisor can help you allocate your funds between the two effectively based on your individual goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon.

Use WiserAdvisor’s free advisor match tool to get matched with seasoned financial advisors who can help guide you on the best strategy to attain your financial goals. Answer a few simple questions based on your financial needs and get matched with 1 to 3 financial advisors who are best suited to help you.